Skip to content

Step 1 of 3 — no typing needed.

What do you need help with?

Buying a homeRefinancing my loanInvestment propertySomething else

★★★★★ 5.0 · 200+ Google reviews

Prefer to talk? Call (02) 7229 7363

Guide

What Is a Comparison Rate, and What It Hides

A comparison rate folds a lender's fees into one rate on a $150,000, 25-year loan. What the law requires, what it leaves out, and why big loans differ.

Portrait of Sina Enayati, Co-Founder & Senior Mortgage Broker

By , Co-Founder & Senior Mortgage Broker

Reviewed by Ansa Ansari,

Published · 8 min read

A large two-storey rendered house in Pymble with a double garage, set on a sloping lawn
Pymble. Photo: Sardaka, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons
On this page8
  1. The legal warning and the example home loan
  2. How a comparison rate is calculated
  3. What the comparison rate leaves out
  4. A hypothetical: when the higher comparison rate is the better deal
  5. Fixed rate home loans and introductory rates
  6. How to compare rates on home loans
  7. The personalised comparison rate on a Key Facts Sheet
  8. Comparison rate or interest rate: how we read them

Ask a lender what is a comparison rate and you’ll get the short version: a single percentage that combines a loan’s interest rate with most of the lender’s fees, so two loans with different fee structures can be lined up on one number. Moneysmart’s definition calls it a rate that helps you work out the true cost of a loan, and the National Credit Code makes it compulsory: a credit advertisement that states an annual percentage rate must also state the comparison rate (section 160), shown no less prominently than the advertised interest rate (section 164).

That’s the textbook answer. The part most explanations skip is that an advertised comparison rate is calculated on one example loan, and for home loans the example is small. On a loan the size most North Shore buyers carry, the same fees move the rate far less, which can change which of two loans looks cheaper.

The regulations list the example amounts and terms a comparison rate can be calculated for, from $250 over two weeks up to $150,000 over 25 years. Section 161 of the National Credit Code says an ad must use whichever one most closely represents the typical loan for that product, which is why personal loan ads quote $10,000 over three years or $30,000 over five, and must say whether the loan is secured. Home loans use the biggest on the list. CommBank’s Simple Home Loan page and Bendigo Bank’s Express Home Loan page both state that basis beside their rates, checked 21 November 2026.

Every advertised comparison rate also carries a warning, and regulation 99 of the National Consumer Credit Protection Regulations prescribes the words. The short version reads: “WARNING: This comparison rate is true only for the examples given and may not include all fees and charges. Different terms, fees or other loan amounts might result in a different comparison rate.” The long version is blunter about what’s missing, saying costs such as redraw fees or early repayment fees, and cost savings such as fee waivers, are not included. Most people read past it. It deserves more attention than it gets, because it’s the law admitting the number’s limits.

How a comparison rate is calculated

All Australian lenders use the same formula, set out in regulation 100 of the regulations. It finds the interest rate at which the money you actually receive, the loan amount less any upfront fees, equals the present value of everything you pay back over the loan term: every repayment plus every credit fee or charge that’s known when the rate is published. The result is stated as a yearly rate, compounding at the repayment frequency, and must be correct to at least 0.01%.

Certain fees are out by design, and which ones count comes down to two rules. Government fees, charges and duties are out, by the regulation’s own wording. Fees whose imposition depends on events that may or may not happen are treated as not ascertainable and left out, under section 166 of the National Credit Code. What’s left is the lender’s own predictable fees and charges: application fees, establishment fees, valuation fees the lender charges at settlement, monthly account keeping fees and annual package fees. Westpac’s explainer adds that its comparison rates include settlement fees and discharge or exit fees too.

So a comparison rate of, say, 6.80% means the loan costs what a fee-free loan at 6.80% would on the $150,000, 25-year example, and nothing more precise than that. It isn’t the rate you pay. Interest is charged at the interest rate in your loan agreement on the loan balance, your repayments are set from that rate, and the fees are charged as they fall due.

You can run the sum yourself. Our comparison rate calculator uses the same formula, and it reproduces the comparison rates on NAB’s Choice Package page to within 0.01%.

What the comparison rate leaves out

The gaps are worth knowing by name, because they’re the additional costs that make two loans with the same comparison rate cost different amounts.

  • Government charges: stamp duty and mortgage registration fees, which the regulation excludes and CommBank’s comparison rate page lists as not included.
  • Fees for events that may not happen, such as fixed rate break costs, redraw fees and late payment fees.
  • Lenders mortgage insurance, which Westpac lists among the costs its comparison rate doesn’t cover.
  • The value of an offset account. CommBank says savings from fee waivers or interest offset arrangements aren’t included, so a package charging $395 a year for an offset shows the fee in its comparison rate but none of the interest the offset saves. Our offset account guide works through when the saving beats the fee.
  • What rates do later. A discount or honeymoon rate is modelled as reverting to today’s variable rate, and nobody knows what that rate will be in two years.

A hypothetical: when the higher comparison rate is the better deal

Here’s a hypothetical with invented rates, run through the code behind our comparison rate calculator. Loan A is a basic variable loan at 6.50% with no fees, and Loan B is a package loan at 6.20% with a $395 annual fee. On the $150,000, 25-year example, Loan A’s comparison rate is 6.50% and Loan B’s is 6.57%, so B, the loan with the lower interest rate, carries the higher comparison rate and looks dearer.

Now run the same two loans as a $1.5 million mortgage over 30 years. Loan B’s comparison rate falls to 6.23%, and the repayment is about $9,187 a month against $9,481 for Loan A. After the fee, B comes out roughly $3,133 ahead in the first year. Over the life of the loan it’s about $94,000 ahead, if neither rate ever moved, which they will.

Same two loans, opposite answers. The $395 is 0.26% of a $150,000 loan each year but 0.03% of $1.5 million, and that ratio is the whole story.

Fixed rate home loans and introductory rates

Fixed rate home loans produce the comparison rates that confuse people most. The comparison rate covers the whole 25-year example, so lenders calculate it as if the loan reverts to their current variable rate when the fixed term ends; Bendigo Bank states that basis in its footnote. NAB’s Choice Package page, correct as at 20 November 2026, shows the effect: a one-year fixed rate of 6.79% carries a comparison rate of 8.79%, because the other 24 years are modelled at a variable rate, and our calculator reproduces NAB’s figure when that rate is the package’s 8.67%.

It cuts the other way too. On Bendigo’s Express Home Loan, checked 21 November 2026, the five-year fixed rate of 6.69% has a comparison rate of 6.67%, lower than the rate itself, because the loan is modelled as reverting to a variable rate of 6.39%. So a fixed comparison rate is mostly a statement about the lender’s variable rate today. That’s useful, within limits. It tells you nothing about the variable rate on the day your fixed term actually ends.

Introductory rates work the same way. As a hypothetical, a loan at 5.99% for two years reverting to 6.69%, with no fees, has a comparison rate of about 6.55% on the standard example, closer to the revert rate than the headline, which is the comparison rate doing its job. What it can’t show is how far the lender moves its variable rate before or after the discount ends.

How to compare rates on home loans

Within its limits, the comparison rate does one job well. Line up two variable home loans of the same type, from any of the mortgage providers in the home loan market, and the same formula on the same $150,000 example shows which one carries more fees at that size: a wide gap between the interest rate and the comparison rate means high fees, and a narrow one means few. That’s a fair test. It’s the use the number was built for.

It works less well across loan products. A fixed rate home loan’s comparison rate leans on the lender’s variable rate, so setting it beside a variable loan’s compares two different assumptions, and interest-only loans have their own basis: CommBank’s comparison rate page says its variable interest-only comparison rates assume an initial five-year interest-only period. A basic loan with no offset account or redraw facility will usually show a lower comparison rate than a package loan, too, and whether the features earn their fees depends on how you’d use them.

For a more accurate picture, put your own loan balance and term into the comparison rate calculator, or get each lender’s Key Facts Sheet, then add the costs the comparison rate never sees, such as stamp duty on a purchase or switching costs on a refinance. If you already have a loan, Moneysmart suggests telling your current lender you’re planning to switch, because it may lower your rate to keep you.

The personalised comparison rate on a Key Facts Sheet

There’s a better number, and the law already requires it. A lender whose website lets you apply for or ask about a standard home loan must let you generate a Key Facts Sheet for it, under section 133AC of the National Consumer Credit Protection Act, and Schedule 5 of the regulations sets its layout. One line on it is a personalised comparison rate, calculated with the regulation 100 formula on the loan amount and term you enter. The sheet also shows the total to be paid back, what you repay for every $1 borrowed, and the lender’s Australian credit licence number. Moneysmart suggests getting the Key Facts Sheet for each loan you’re comparing, based on the amount you’re likely to borrow.

Comparison rate or interest rate: how we read them

Our view, which some lenders’ marketing teams would argue with: for loans the size most North Shore buyers now take on, the advertised comparison rate is the least useful number in the ad. The Code says the point is to help people identify the true cost of credit (section 157), and on a $150,000 loan, the amount in regulation 97, it still does that well. On a seven-figure loan it mostly rewards lenders for charging no fees, whatever their rate.

When Sina has two offers in front of him for a refinancing client, he asks each lender for a Key Facts Sheet on the client’s actual balance and term, then weighs those personalised rates against the loan options and features the client will really use, such as an offset account or a redraw facility. What neither he nor any calculator can tell you is where the variable rate goes next. Rates move. If you’re weighing a switch from an existing home loan, the refinance calculator adds the switching costs and the month they’re paid back, the guide to refinancing costs lists each one, and our big banks versus non-bank lenders guide covers how the two kinds of lender price their loans. This is general information that doesn’t take into account your objectives, financial situation or needs.

Sources

  1. moneysmart.gov.au Moneysmart's definition
  2. legislation.gov.au National Credit Code
  3. legislation.gov.au regulations
  4. commbank.com.au Simple Home Loan page
  5. bendigobank.com.au Express Home Loan page
  6. westpac.com.au explainer
  7. nab.com.au Choice Package page
  8. commbank.com.au CommBank's comparison rate page
  9. moneysmart.gov.au Moneysmart
  10. moneysmart.gov.au Moneysmart

Talk to a broker in under a minute

Three quick taps, then your details, and a real broker replies within one business day.

★★★★★ 5.0 · 200+ Google reviews

5.0 from 200+ Google reviewsRead every one of them on our profile
6 industry award wins & nominationsRecognised across the broking industry
Family-run, four brokersOne office, at 4 Kamilaroy Rd
No cost to youLender-paid, disclosed in writing. ACL 509484

Talk to a broker in under a minute

A real broker replies within one business day — usually much faster

Step 1 of 3 — no typing needed

Is this your first home loan?

Prefer to talk? Call (02) 7229 7363

★★★★★ 5.0 · 200+ Google reviewsCredit representatives of Buyers Choice Licencing Pty Ltd · ACL 509484