Interest only vs principal and interest home loans: the repayment after the switch
On an interest only home loan your repayments cover the interest component and nothing else, so the loan balance on the last day of the interest only period is the amount you borrowed. Then the loan reverts to principal and interest over whatever is left of the term, and Moneysmart’s first warning is to make sure you can afford that higher repayment. Most interest only calculators lead with the low number. This one leads with the repayment after the switch.
The rates matter more than people assume. The RBA splits its average rates on new loans by repayment type, and in September 2026 owner-occupier interest only loans averaged 7.00% against 6.14% for principal and interest loans, while for investors the gap was far narrower, 6.51% against 6.33% (RBA table F6, published 6 November 2026). The calculator adds those gaps to 6.73%, so the starting rates move with the cash rate.
The risk sits in the years you pay nothing off the loan’s principal. If property prices don’t rise while the mortgage is interest only, you build no equity, and Moneysmart notes that leaves you exposed in a downturn or if you need to sell. Its suggestions for the switch are sensible ones: work up to the higher home loan repayments early if your loan takes extra repayments, and ask for a better interest rate or refinance, as long as the saving beats the cost of switching. None of that removes the debt.
Three home loans, both ways
Two of our made-up households, at owner-occupier averages, and the Chatswood loan again priced as an investment. Each is 30 years with 5 years interest only, and the repayments are monthly and rounded.
| Loan | Amount | IO / P&I rate | Interest only | P&I from day one | After year 5 | Extra interest |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Chatswood, their home | $928,000 | 7.59% / 6.73% | $5,870 | $6,007 | $6,400 | $109,762 |
| Turramurra, their home | $2,063,000 | 7.59% / 6.73% | $13,048 | $13,353 | $14,227 | $244,008 |
| Chatswood loan, as an investment | $928,000 | 7.10% / 6.92% | $5,491 | $6,124 | $6,512 | $78,206 |
Read the Chatswood rows together. As their home, interest only saves the couple about $137 a month against principal and interest, because the owner-occupier premium swallows most of the cash flow it frees up, and it costs them about $109,762 more in total interest over the 30 years. Priced as an investment the monthly saving is $634. That is a real difference.
Why lenders test it over the shorter term
APRA’s prudential guide APG 223 expects banks to assess an interest only loan on a principal and interest basis over the term those repayments actually apply to, excluding the interest only period, and with the serviceability buffer, which APRA kept at 3 percentage points in May 2026. On the Chatswood investment loan that means repayments tested at 9.92% over 25 years instead of 30, and the same income supports about 3.5% less loan. The same guide says asking for a longer interest only period triggers a new assessment, and CommBank caps any one interest only period at five years (checked 21 November 2026).
Our view, and what this can’t tell you
For a home you live in, at average pricing, we think interest only is a poor trade nearly every time, and we’ll say so even though the loan pays us the same either way. For investors it can be a sound cash flow structure. Taking it only for the tax deductions makes little sense, though. A deduction refunds your marginal rate on each dollar of interest, so the extra interest still leaves you behind. The negative gearing calculator shows that cost after tax, and the negative gearing guide covers the 2026 rule changes.
Ansa’s first question to an investor asking for interest only is where the freed-up cash goes. If it pays down a home loan whose interest isn’t deductible, the structure can earn its premium.
A caveat on the tool itself. It holds both rates flat for the full loan term, charges no fees, works in monthly repayments only and ignores any offset balance, so treat it as an estimate. It also can’t tell you whether a lender will agree: APG 223 expects owner-occupier interest only to have a sound, documented reason, and not being able to afford principal and interest isn’t one, so that is a loan we can’t place. The repayment calculator runs the principal and interest side with rate moves and a choice of repayment frequency, and the investment lending page covers how we structure investor loans. The ATO’s interest rules look at what the money bought, not the repayment type, and your accountant rules on your own deductions.