How the comparison rate calculator works
The formula isn’t ours. Regulation 100 of the National Consumer Credit Protection Regulations 2010 sets it out: find the interest rate at which the money you receive, less the lender’s upfront fees, equals everything you pay back over the loan term, repayments and ongoing fees included, then state it as a yearly rate compounded monthly. Put another way, it’s the internal rate of return once the fees are added. The comparison rate calculator finds that rate by halving the gap between a guess that’s too low and one that’s too high until it’s accurate to far better than the 0.01% the regulation asks for.
Government fees stay out of the calculator, as the regulation says. So do fees that may or may not happen, which the National Credit Code (section 166) treats as not ascertainable.
We tested it against a lender’s own published figures. NAB’s Choice Package page, correct as at 20 November 2026 and checked the next day, lists a variable rate of 8.67% with a comparison rate of 9.01%, and fixed rates from one to five years with theirs, all on a $395 annual package fee; this comparison rate calculator reproduces every one of them to within 0.01%. The package is closed to new borrowers, but the arithmetic is the same for any loan. That’s the check that matters.
Where to find the numbers the calculator needs
Start on the lender’s own product page. Section 164 of the National Credit Code says an advertised comparison rate can’t be less prominent than the interest rate beside it, so the two sit together, usually with the fees in the small print or a fee schedule underneath. Upfront fees are the application, establishment or valuation fees charged at settlement, and ongoing fees are the monthly service fee or the annual package fee. Moneysmart’s guide to choosing a home loan describes the comparison rate as a single figure that combines the interest rate and most fees. It’s the “most” that this calculator lets you test.
Here’s a quick check that you’ve found every fee: set the loan to $150,000 over 25 years, and the comparison rate calculator should land on the lender’s advertised comparison rate or within a few hundredths of it. If it comes out lower, a fee is missing, or the lender times its fees differently. A discharge fee is the usual suspect.
For a fixed or introductory rate, enter the length of the fixed period in years and the rate the loan reverts to after it. Then change the amount and term to your own.
Why the comparison rate on your loan comes out lower
An advertised comparison rate has to be calculated for whichever of the loan sizes and lengths listed in regulation 97 is closest to the lender’s typical loan, and the biggest on that list is $150,000 over 25 years. Home loans use it. A 20% deposit on Chatswood’s median unit, $1,160,000 in the March 2026 quarter (NSW Rent and Sales Report), still means borrowing $928,000.
Fees are fixed dollar amounts, so on a bigger balance they lift the rate less. Here is the same rate, 6.73%, with two real fee structures: a $395 annual package fee, which NAB’s package charges, and the CommBank Simple Home Loan’s $300 establishment fee and $10 a month, checked 21 November 2026. The calculator’s example households borrow over 30 years, which spreads the fees further again. Same fees, very different rates. The repayments in each row are identical; only the fees change between the columns.
| Loan | Amount | Term | $395 a year | $300 upfront, $10 a month |
|---|
| The regulated benchmark | $150,000 | 25 years | 7.09% | 6.86% |
| First home in Hornsby | $675,000 | 30 years | 6.81% | 6.76% |
| A bigger unit in Chatswood | $928,000 | 30 years | 6.79% | 6.75% |
| Upgrading to a Turramurra house | $2,063,000 | 30 years | 6.75% | 6.74% |
That gap has a consequence the bank ads don’t mention. Take a hypothetical, run through the same calculator with invented pricing: a package loan at 6.43% with the $395 fee, against a fee-free loan at 6.73%. On the benchmark the package shows a comparison rate of 6.79%, so it looks dearer. On the Chatswood loan it comes out at 6.49%, comfortably the cheaper of the two, and the fee-free one stays at 6.73% whatever the size.
Our view, which plenty of lenders would dispute: above a few hundred thousand dollars borrowed, the advertised comparison rate tells you more about a lender’s fee schedule than about what you will pay. It isn’t useless. It was built for a smaller balance than most North Shore buyers take out, and the comparison rate on your own amount, which the calculator above gives you, is the number worth putting side by side.
What a good comparison rate looks like next to the interest rate
There’s no single good comparison rate, because every home loan rate moves with the cash rate. The useful number is the gap. A comparison rate equal to the interest rate means the loan has no lender fees the regulation 100 formula can count, and every fee widens it. On the benchmark loan at 6.73%, this calculator puts each $100 of annual fee at 0.09 of a percentage point and each $1,000 of upfront fee at 0.07; on the $928,000 Chatswood loan over 30 years the same fees add about 0.01 each.
So a wide gap on an ad flags a heavy fee schedule, which matters most on a small loan. The warning printed beside every advertised comparison rate, quoted in our guide to what a comparison rate is, says different amounts and terms give different rates.
What the comparison rate calculator leaves out
Break costs, redraw fees and late fees aren’t in it, and neither are stamp duty or registration fees. The law leaves them out. Nor is any saving: CommBank’s comparison rate explainer says cost savings such as fee waivers or interest offset arrangements are left out, which matters if the package fee buys you an offset (our offset account guide shows when that pays). A fixed or intro comparison rate also assumes today’s revert rate holds for the years after it.
And it assumes you pay only the scheduled repayment for the whole loan term; extra repayments cut the interest on any loan, as the extra repayments calculator shows. Whether a lender charges for them is one of the questions Moneysmart suggests asking before you choose, along with break costs and fees for using loan features, because the Key Facts Sheet doesn’t include every feature or condition.
We can’t see a lender’s full fee schedule from here, so the calculator is only as complete as the fees you enter. Exit fees are the grey area: Westpac’s explainer says its comparison rates include discharge or exit fees but not lenders mortgage insurance, other lenders leave exit fees out, and that’s why the box is optional. The figure to trust is the personalised comparison rate on the lender’s Key Facts Sheet, which uses the same formula on your amount and term, and which a lender’s website must let you generate under section 133AC of the National Consumer Credit Protection Act.
When Sina compares refinance offers, he sets the advertised comparison rate aside and prices each loan on the client’s own balance with every fee in, which is the sum this comparison rate calculator does. If you’re weighing a switch, the refinance calculator adds the switching costs and when they’re paid back, and the guide to the cost of refinancing lists each one.